There is some mystery about Sarah Colyer who married Peter Scholl as well. Spraker mentions that she was a Scotch woman and Peter's second wife1. The Family History Center and Spraker note that Peter and Sarah had two children, Deborah in 1728 (baptized September 11, 1728) and William (Willem) in 1731 (baptized March 31, 1730/31). Record of their baptisms is found in the Harlingen Church in New Jersey.
One Collier researcher (Wade Collier) has uncovered some additional information that more definitively shows that a Sarah Colyear was married to a Peter Scholl and lived in Somerset County, NJ. If this is our Sarah Colyer, he also then provides her lineage:
Thomas (b abt 1576, possibly Devon, Eng; d 1647, Hingham, MS)
Wife Susannah (b perhaps 1591; d 1667, Hingham, Mass.)
↓
Moses (b about 1625, probably Eng;
d March 17, 1684/5, Woodbridge, NJ)
Second wife, Elizabeth Bullard (d after 1690, probably Woodbridge, NJ)
↓
Thomas (b before June 5, 1664, Hingham, Mass.; d after 1719, probably Woodbridge, NJ)
Wife Hannah Dennis (b before 1672;
d about 1711, probably Woodbridge, NJ)
↓
Sarah (born July 2, 1705, in Woodbridge, NJ)
Another researcher, Andrew Provost, in the Calyer Family (1951) writes another background for Sarah Calyer. Here she was �baptized May29, 1705, in the Brooklyn Dutch Church as child of Jan �Chellwer� and Sara �Luwiss�. She married Pieter Scholl, probable son of David Scholl of Raritan, New Jersey, and grandson of Pieter Jansen Scholl and his wife, Margaretta Provost (N. Y. G&B Soc. Record Vol. X No. 3)�. He also shows the same children for Peter and Sarah.
Her lineage in this scenario is shown as:
Jochem (bap February 9, 1653; d 1658); Wife Magdalena Waele)
↓
Jacobus, (died by July 5, 1720; Wife Maria de Witt)
↓
Johannes (born about 1682 probably in New York City,
moved to Bushwick, Long Island in about 1700; d aft 1750);
Wife Sara Luwiss)
↓
Sara (baptized May 29, 1705 in Brooklyn Dutch Church)
Both agree about 1705 being the year of birth which fits with our Sarah. I lean toward Sarah being the child of parents who lived in New Jersey when she was born in 1705. The Long Island parents stayed there throughout their lifetimes which would make it more difficult for Sarah to meet and marry a Peter Scholl in New Jersey.